In the early 1930s, two gold prospectors set off a dynamite charge in the Pedro Mountains of Carbon County, Wyoming, hoping the smoke would clear on a vein of ore. What they found was a cave, and inside it, on a ledge a few feet off the ground, a man. He sat cross-legged like the Buddha, eyes bulging, mouth twisted into an odd grin. He stood about half a foot tall and weighed maybe a pound.
Scientists x-rayed him, showmen charged a quarter to see him, and a car dealer tried to sell sedans with him. Then he disappeared.
Gold fever in Carbon County
Cecil Maine of Alliance, Nebraska, caught a wicked case of gold fever and headed west with a fellow prospector named Frank Carr. Wyoming's gold rush had mostly played out by the end of the 19th century, but the rumors never stopped. Carbon County sat snug against Sweetwater and Fremont counties, where gold had been found, and its ground was rich in coal and minerals. Maine and Carr had spotted a glint of color on a rock face near the town of Leo, and that was enough.
It was a feverish era. In Rock Springs, gold hunters tried to trace a hen whose gizzard had coughed up eight small nuggets. So the men lit the fuse. Maine wriggled into the little chamber the blast had opened, shined his light on the ledge, and decided that whatever he was looking at was worth taking.
When the two showed their find around Casper the next day, people laughed at them and called it a prank. Soon enough the state historian, Mrs. Cyrus Beard, had the mummy in her temporary care, and newspapers were calling it a mummified pygmy, possibly the ancestor of the American Indian. Frank Carr died shortly after the discovery. Naturally, there were whispers of a curse.
The little people of the mountains
Wyoming already had a story waiting for him. The Shoshone and Paiute people told of the Numidaka, a race of mountain dwarves no taller than three feet, with rows of sharp teeth, tiny bows that fired poison-tipped arrows, and a gift for dark magic. Their name came from the Shoshone and Paiute words for cannibal. They stole children. By legend, they killed their own sick and injured with a single blow to the head and then ate them. It took generations of war, and the Rocky Mountain tribes joining forces, to wipe them out.
Tiny adults in the ground weren't unheard of, either. In the 1800s, a farmer named Turner Lane plowed up grave after grave along the Caney Fork near Sparta, Tennessee: small skeletons laid carefully in coffins of bluish limestone, each buried with pipes, bowls and a black clay vessel holding a conch shell. The skulls held adult teeth. Estimates ran to some 75,000 graves. A geologist named George Featherstonhaugh argued they were secondary burials, meaning the bones of normal-sized adults left out on scaffolds until the weather stripped them clean and then buried in compact graves. More so-called pygmy cemeteries turned up in Ohio, Missouri and Coffey County. So when word of a pound-sized mummy got around, plenty of Americans shrugged. Why not?
From drugstore window to car lot
In April 1934, Maine sold the mummy, now called Pedro, to Homer F. Sherrill of Crawford, Nebraska. Sherrill hotly denied a report that the American Museum of Natural History had called it a prematurely born baby, and the museum backed him up: it had never examined the thing. Sherrill claimed Harvard specialists had x-rayed it, and that he'd loaned it to the Field Museum in Chicago, which has no record of it. What's certain is that he put Pedro in a bell jar on a wooden pedestal inside a tent in Casper and charged 25 cents a look.
Pedro moved on to a drugstore owned by Floyd Jones, who put him in the front window, rented him out, and sold souvenir postcards like crazy, until he got nervous someone would steal him. He sold Pedro for a reported few thousand dollars to a car dealer named Ivan Goodman, known as Honest Ivan, who advertised hard: "It's educational, it's scientific, it will amaze and thrill you." When the mummy failed to move cars off the lot, Goodman took him to carnivals, fairs and college campuses.
The one artifact that might have settled whether tiny people once lived in the Wyoming mountains was x-rayed and confirmed human, then used to sell cars. It hasn't been seen since it passed to the head of a lonely hearts club in Florida.
A human adult, then nothing
In the late 1940s, Goodman handed Pedro to Dr. Harry Shapiro, curator of biological anthropology at the American Museum of Natural History. The x-rays showed human vertebrae and other clearly human bones: no doll, no gaff. Shapiro wanted microscopic and chemical tests, but the owner took the mummy back to Wyoming first. His verdict stood anyway: this little thing, he said, was a human adult, and the first evidence he'd seen of a race of little men on the continent.
Then Pedro vanished. On another trip to New York City, he was lost, sold or loaned to Leonard Wadler, who ran the Cultural Resource Center. Despite the name, it was a lonely hearts club that promoted the virtues of staying single. Wadler moved to Florida and gave private showings of Pedro through 1975. He died in 1980, and his family said they had no idea where the mummy was.
A child on a ledge
In 1994, University of Wyoming professor Dr. George Gill went on Unsolved Mysteries and said the specialists he trusted saw an infant with anencephaly, a severe birth defect in which a baby is born missing parts of its brain and skull and survives a few days at most. Because the brain never develops, such infants can have the proportions of tiny adults. Eugene Bashor, who had begged his father for the 25 cents during the Depression and spent 50 years hunting for Pedro, pushed back: the mummy had a full set of prominent teeth, not the undeveloped ones a baby would have.
After the broadcast, a family in Cheyenne offered Gill a mummy of their own, bought by a relative from a sheep herder in 1929 and kept in a trunk in the attic. They called her Chiquita. She was the size of a potato, with blonde hair, and she sat posed just like Pedro. Testing at the Children's Hospital of Denver confirmed anencephaly, and her DNA showed she was Native American. Gill had examined hundreds of prehistoric burials and seen nothing like these two anywhere. The only other mummified anencephalic infant ever found came out of an Egyptian tomb.
If that's what Pedro was, then someone long ago tucked a baby carefully onto a raised ledge in a cave rather than leaving him for the wolves. As Sheri Lynch put it: "But he was still loved." Centuries later, he was a roadside attraction. Her best guess is that he ended up in a black trash bag, headed for a Florida landfill.
