In March 1937, a new mother stepped into the shower of a Miami hotel suite, her bags packed for a trip to her dying father's bedside. Minutes later, a mob splintered the bathroom door and burst in on her, soaking wet and naked, yelling, "We finally got you with the goods!" At the front of the crowd stood her own husband.
Her name was Monaei Lindley, and before she was done she would walk down the aisle eight times.
A rich girl, a hard town
Moneye was born in Cleveland, Ohio, on August 13, 1908, to a very successful father and a life of wealth and privilege. She wanted the one thing money couldn't simply hand her. "Ever since I can remember, I have always wanted to be an actress," she said. "I came of Quaker stock, and my father was opposed to the theater." He sent her off to schools, to girls' camp, even to Europe. She kept coming back to it.
In Los Angeles they called her "Hollywood's poor little rich girl." Her wardrobe and social connections opened fewer doors than she'd hoped. People assumed a girl who didn't need the money was just after a thrill. Still, she fought her way into three pictures: Tangled Destinies, Listening In, and 1933's Girl from Georgia, a movie banned from many theaters for offending public morality. In it, her character loses her man to a girl named Waffles.
Then, fresh off the lead in a stage production called Between the Covers, she met Wallace Groves. Wally took four college degrees to Wall Street, spun one idea into a million-dollar investment fund, and once raked in over $360,000 profit in a single day, a streak so dazzling the Securities and Exchange Commission came poking around. After a whirlwind courtship, the couple settled into a Park Avenue penthouse. Moneye had a trust fund worth millions of her own, so she didn't need a nickel from him. Their son, Wallace Jr., arrived, and the fairy tale looked complete.
The raid in Miami
Baby Wallace was only a few weeks old when Wally suggested a Miami vacation: sunshine, fresh air, orange juice. He promptly chartered a luxury yacht, the Louisa Jane, for a seven-day cruise to the Bahamas with eight guests. Back in Miami, a telegram waited for Moneye. Her father was dying in Philadelphia. She planned to leave the next evening.
Then came the shower and the door. Crowding into that bathroom were her brother-in-law and his wife, a woman from the yacht, a well-known New York City detective named William Ryan, the hotel clerk, a bellboy, and Wally. They left as fast as they came, laughing, slapping backs, heading for the bar. What they had actually discovered was Moneye shampooing her hair.
Why stage such a thing? In New York, where the couple lived, adultery was the only grounds for ending a marriage, and those laws weren't reformed until 1966. A man who wanted out had to cook up a case. Back then, hotel raids were how you cooked it. Vice laws, the statutes policing sex and morality, made fornication and adultery crimes, and detectives in fedoras kicked in hotel doors to prove it.
Moneye went to her father anyway. A week later she came home to divorce papers, and worse, an empty nursery. Five years after the Lindbergh baby was kidnapped and murdered, her son was gone. Wally had told the baby's nurse to hide the child in a hotel, and he let the charade run a full week before sending the boy home and dropping his lawsuit.
Moneye was having none of it. Wally paid for a trip to Reno, the hub of what became known as "the migratory divorce trade," the business of couples traveling to states with looser laws to end their marriages. She won full custody and a $135,000 settlement. Then, learning the raiding party had told hotel guests she'd been caught unclad and up to something licentious, she sued the whole lot of them, first for half a million dollars, then for a million. Hell hath no fury like a woman falsely accused and mocked in public by a bellboy.
Monaei Lindley married eight times, starting with a husband who staged a raid on her shower to invent an adultery case. Yet when she died, Nevada's newspapers wrote about her Arabian horses and not one word about the husbands.
Love, again and again
She bought a ranch in Reno and fell for her foreman, Paul Peterson, a cowhand with a pencil mustache. They married in 1939, honeymooned in New York, and split that December. Peterson could have claimed half her fortune under Nevada law. Instead he kissed her on the cheek and rode off into the sunset.
Husband three, attorney Gordon Rice, took her to Havana and New Orleans. Back home, he crashed their car into a culvert. Moneye suffered a fractured thigh and a crushed chest, and the marriage didn't last a year. Husband four, German landscape painter Louis Heinsmann, lasted under six months, and Moneye often denied the marriage was legal at all. Husband five was former deputy sheriff Edward Cupit, one consonant away from Cupid, who married her on May 21, 1941, less than 24 hours after his own divorce. With that ring still gleaming, she flew to New York to testify against Wally at his securities fraud trial. He got two years in prison.
In 1943 came rancher Domenic Peri. When he joined the Army and shipped out to the Pacific, she divorced him for leaving her to run the ranch alone. Husband seven, sculptor and hypnotist Al Price, held a séance at the wedding party. He put a ranch hand into a trance, and to prove the trance was real, a guest touched the man with a lit cigarette. No reaction. Then the entranced ranch hand announced the newlyweds' fate: move to an artists' colony in California, use fake names, study philosophy. The spirits had spoken. Off they went in Monaei's bright yellow car, her Siamese cat on her lap. Eighteen months later she was back in Reno. The hypnotist wasn't.
The ranch at Cinnabar Hill
She reclaimed her leased ranch, sued the tenant, and won. She acted in community theater, earning rapturous reviews in 1949 as Constance in The Women. She donated an Appaloosa horse to a rodeo raffle, encouraged horsemanship among Native Americans in the area, and helped stage a benefit for the VFW. In 1955 she married an eighth and final time, to Edwin, a power company foreman. Edwin and her grown son, the former baby Wally, now going by Norman, once survived a freezing night on the shore of Pyramid Lake after a storm. The marriage didn't survive much longer.
In 1964 she was charged with reckless driving after striking two parked cars. Five years later, a fire, likely started by a neglected cigarette, tore through her Cinnabar Hill ranch in Sparks, Nevada. Fire trucks slid through snow, and with too little water at the scene, crews pumped from the indoor swimming pool in her basement. She was 60, though almost every reporter got her age wrong.
The Nevada papers skipped Hollywood, the prison sentence and the eight weddings. The Nevada State Journal wrote instead that "her Arabian horses were recognized as one of the finest in the West, winning many ribbons in various shows." At a time when women were defined by their husbands, the woman with eight of them was remembered for her own work. What had her money really bought her? "It's not happiness that money buys, it's freedom."
