On a stormy night in 1770, a half-drowned young sailor pounded on the door of Loftus Hall on Ireland's Hook Peninsula. The family took him in, dried him off and let him stay. A few weeks later, according to the family's own account, he revealed himself at the card table as the devil and blasted out through the roof in a ball of fire.
Strange things had been happening on that patch of County Wexford for a very long time before he arrived, and they kept happening long after he left.
Sacred ground, then stone walls
Long before any house stood there, the land belonged to the druids, the priest class of the ancient Celts. They left no writing of their own, so most of what's known about them comes from their enemies, the Romans. Julius Caesar wrote that the druids were "engaged in things sacred, conduct the public and private sacrifices and interpret all matters of religion." He also described wicker men, giant human figures woven from sticks, stuffed with living people and set on fire. Still, Rome didn't turn on the druids because it thought they were savages. It went after them because they were brilliant: astronomers, engineers, healers and leaders who held the loyalty of the Celtic people. Wexford is dotted with what they left behind, including the Robinstown Great Stone Circle and a shrine at Carnsore Point in a place whose Gaelic name means the Meadow of the Women.
Christianity pushed the druids aside, and around 1200 a Norman knight named Raymond Le Gros laid the first foundation stones on their ground. (Le Gros means "the fat," which is a rough thing to be known for eight centuries later.) When the Black Death reached his family's door in 1350, they tore the house down, moved farther down the peninsula and built Redmond Hall. Then came the civil wars of the 1640s. Alexander Redmond, a 68-year-old rebel sympathizer, held off English forces with only nine men, one of them a wandering tailor who happened to be visiting. Redmond managed to stay on until he died, but his heirs lost the land. An English aristocrat, Nicholas Loftus, got hold of the battered house, and in 1666 his son Henry moved in to make it the family seat. From then on it was Loftus Hall.
The stranger at the card table
Charles Tottenham married Anne Loftus and took her family's name to secure the inheritance. Anne died suddenly, leaving six children, and Charles later married his cousin, Jane Cliffe. On the night of the storm, the only people at home were Charles, Jane and his youngest daughter, also named Anne.
The sailor was beautiful, with large, dark, almost magnetic eyes, and young Anne was transfixed. For days they walked the gardens and browsed the library, nearly always with a chaperone watching. Then, during an after-dinner card game, Anne found she'd been dealt only two cards. She bent to pick up the third from the floor and saw that the guest's legs ended not in polished boots but in two cloven hooves. She screamed, and he laughed. According to the story, he told the room that they knew him by another name, "Lucifer," then turned into a ball of fire and shot through the ceiling.
Anne never recovered. She stopped eating and sleeping and kept insisting her lover would come back for her. Her family shut her away in the tapestry room, where she sat with her knees tucked under her chin and watched the sea. She died there. Her body had stiffened so badly that, supposedly, she had to be buried sitting up. When the family mausoleum was broken into in the 1940s, police noticed one oddly shaped coffin. Her father sealed the tomb in cement, officially to keep out grave robbers. Locals whispered that it was really to keep Anne from rising to rejoin her demon lover.
The family's own story was that Satan had courted their daughter. A century later, workers found an infant's skeleton sealed inside the wall of the room where she'd been locked away, which suggests the family preferred saying they'd hosted the devil to admitting she was pregnant.
What was in the wall
Not everyone believed the family. Some said the sailor was just a sailor whom Lord Charles judged too lowborn to marry his daughter. Others said the stranger got Anne pregnant and left, and that the tapestry room was really a place to hide her.
After her death, furniture turned up overturned and objects flew through the air. The burned hole in the drawing-room ceiling wouldn't stay patched, no matter what the carpenters tried. A priest, Father Thomas Broaders, performed an exorcism, a religious rite to drive out demons, and was so proud of it that his tombstone reads: "Here lies the body of Thomas Broaders who did good and prayed for all and banished the devil from Loftus Hall."
The house stayed haunted anyway. In 1790 a guest named Mr. Reed woke to growling as unseen hands ripped away his bed curtains and blankets. A manservant saw a young woman in a silk gown appear beside his bed and refused to go back into the room. Then, during repairs in the 1870s, workers opening a plaster wall in the tapestry room found the tiny skeleton of an infant.
The family kept it quiet. One likely reason for the wall: under older Catholic teaching, a stillborn baby had never drawn breath, so it wasn't considered to have a soul and couldn't be baptized or given a funeral. Burying a bundle in the garden meant the gardeners might see. Sealing it inside a wall meant nobody would ever know Anne had given birth. The family found a devil in the drawing room easier to live with than an unwed pregnancy.
Nuns, a hotel, a new name
Lady Jane Loftus later poured money into renovations to lure Queen Victoria for a visit. The queen never came, and the debt bankrupted the family. The 22-bedroom house sat empty until Benedictine nuns bought it in 1917. The Sisters of Providence came after them and later left in such a hurry that they didn't pack everything. Michael Devereaux opened a hotel there in 1983 and died on the property. His widow tried to run it alone, then left one night and abandoned everything she owned.
Aidan Quigley and his siblings bought it in 2011 and turned it into a ghost-tour attraction. Quigley had been a skeptic until he moved in and found that a crucifix and a massive statue of Christ, both left behind by the nuns, kept showing up in different places. "There's far more dead than living around there," he told the Irish Independent. In 2015 a tourist named Thomas Beavis photographed the house and later spotted a young girl and an older woman standing in a window. Nobody has debunked the photo.
The new owners are renaming the place Ladyville House, a luxury hotel. Its website talks up old-world charm and says nothing about Anne Tottenham, her suitor or the hole in the roof that won't stay fixed.
