Case file 007Space, Aliens & Big ScienceModern (1980–today)

True Space Cowboys

In 1997, two Columbia astronauts, held down only by boot straps, spent hours waiting to grab a tumbling 3,000-pound satellite with their hands.

Feb 24, 202321 min
00:00 / 21:22
Or listen to this episode onApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTube
Share this episode

In this episode

  • Why Columbia had to do a 180-degree roll at 13 times the speed of sound, and the budget cut behind it
  • The 1972 sales pitch that skipped the stars and promised to do 'many useful things'
  • A $10 million satellite that refused to do its pirouette, and what happened when the robotic arm reached for it
  • One chance, one telescope, two gloved hands: the grab that had to happen at the exact same second
  • What Winston Scott felt the first time he looked down at the Earth from outside the shuttle

“Well, of course, you are falling. That’s how you stay in orbit. You’re literally falling around the Earth.”

The story

On Monday, November 24th, 1997, while most of America was shopping for cargo pants at a new store called Old Navy, two men stood on the outside of a space shuttle more than 170 miles overhead. Only straps on their boots held them in place. They were waiting to catch a tumbling 3,000-pound satellite with their gloved hands, and almost nobody down on the ground was paying attention.

Earth had other things going on. Ally McBeal ruled television, Mortal Kombat Annihilation was the country's number one movie, and a thrilling new thing called text messaging worked only if the sender and the receiver were on the same cellular network. Titanic was about to open in theaters. Everyone was eating fistfuls of Nabisco SnackWell's cookies, since fat-free supposedly meant you could eat all of them.

Sold on a modest budget

The story begins in January 1972, when NASA announced the space shuttle program under President Richard Nixon. The government official pitching it skipped all the lofty talk about frontiers and the unknown. His case was that the shuttle could be built on a modest budget, that it would make space operations less complex and less costly, and that "the space shuttle is needed to do many useful things." He also promised it would be open to all the nations of the world.

Things moved fast anyway. Within four years NASA was testing the Enterprise orbiter. Columbia later circled the Earth 37 times before landing safely at Edwards Air Force Base with Robert L. Crippen and John W. Young aboard. Hardly anyone can name them, yet everyone can name the whole Scooby Doo gang. By 1984 Bruce McCandless II was floating untethered outside Challenger, and that crew landed right where it had launched, which is more than an airline can always promise.

Grief, then a blurry telescope

In 1986, 73 seconds into its 10th mission, Challenger broke apart in flight. All seven crew members were killed, including a schoolteacher. That night President Ronald Reagan told a grieving nation that the crew had "slipped the surly bonds of Earth to touch the face of God." The shuttle program survived, but NASA's civilians-in-space initiative did not. Civilians would wait another 35 years to go up, until billionaire Richard Branson beat billionaire Jeff Bezos into space by eight days.

The wins kept coming. In 1990, Discovery's crew deployed the Hubble telescope, which cost more than a billion dollars, at the highest orbital altitude the shuttle program had ever attempted. Then everyone learned that a mistake in making Hubble's primary mirror had left its view a little blurry. Three years later, two teams of astronauts made a world-record five spacewalks and fixed its eyesight.

A flip to save a few bucks

In November 1997, Columbia launched on its 24th mission, a routine one. Racing toward orbit at 13 times the speed of sound, it rolled 180 degrees. NASA said the move wasn't dangerous, just necessary. Its tracking station in Bermuda was about to be shut down to save money, and without the flip the crew couldn't make radio contact with the satellites that relayed its communications.

This crew included astronauts from Japan, Ukraine and India. Twenty-five years late, "foreign visitors from all over the world" were finally riding the shuttle, just as promised. Their job was to release a small satellite called Spartan, which would spend two days studying the sun's outer atmosphere, solar winds and charged particles. That kind of solar activity can wreak havoc on power grids and radio systems back on Earth. After that, the crew would bring Spartan back aboard.

The weird part

In 1997, NASA's fix for a broken, tumbling 3,000-pound satellite was to send two astronauts outside with only their boots strapped down. They waited more than three hours to grab it with their gloved hands, and both had to grab it at the same instant.

The satellite wouldn't dance

Astronaut Kalpana Chawla released Spartan, and it failed to perform what NASA calls a pirouette, the move that shows all of a satellite's systems are working. She tried the space version of turning it off and on again: grabbing it back with Columbia's 50-foot robotic arm. Anyone who has lost a stuffed Pikachu to an arcade claw game knows how that went. Worse, the failed grab set the satellite slowly spinning, and that put it all but out of the arm's reach.

Spartan was five feet square, weighed 3,000 pounds and cost $10 million, at a time when NASA couldn't afford a tracking station in Bermuda. Letting it fall back to Earth and burn up was out of the question. So astronauts Doy and Winston Scott suited up and stepped out into minus 455 degrees Fahrenheit, moving at about 17,500 miles an hour with the whole planet floating in front of them.

One chance, by hand

For safety, they stood at opposite ends of the cargo bay, their boots strapped down more loosely than you'd be buckled into a roller coaster. Columbia inched toward the tumbling satellite. Both men had to grab a telescope sticking out of Spartan's side at exactly the same instant, timed to the second. They had one chance. The wait stretched past three hours. At any point they could have asked to come back inside, and a fraction of a second too early or too late would have ruined the whole mission.

Instead, they snatched the dead satellite out of its doomed tumble and saved NASA $10 million. Then they calmly asked whether they could bring it aboard, sounding about as excited as someone asking for the salt.

Columbia would later meet a heartbreaking end, but not on this trip. Scott later tried to put the feeling into words. On his first spacewalk, he pulled himself up the side of the payload bay and looked down at the Earth racing by far below. "And I had the sensation I was falling." He was sure he would tumble over and hit the ground. He was falling, of course. That's what orbit is.

The transcript

Chapters & full transcript3,105 words
Chapters
  1. 01:41Down here in 1997
  2. 02:46A shuttle on a modest budget
  3. 05:37Tragedy and a blurry telescope
  4. 08:28Columbia's routine mission
  5. 12:10The satellite that wouldn't pirouette
  6. 14:02Caught by hand

This transcript was generated automatically from the episode audio and may contain errors. Times are approximate, since ad breaks can shift them by a minute or two.

00:00

Since there are fewer than 75 people in the whole world with hyperthymesia, that's the technical term for perfect memory, you probably don't remember what you were up to on Monday, November 24th, 1997. I sure don't. I'm all like, I don't know, something, something, Spice Girls, something, something, Nintendo 64, something, something, Clinton administration?

00:27

What if I told you that while we were all busy checking out cargo pants at this new store called Old Navy that was suddenly everywhere, two human beings were rocketing through the vacuum of space, more than 170 miles above our heads, moving at thousands of miles per hour. Oh yeah. And they were not in a spacecraft. They were standing on a spacecraft tethered to the surface of the ship by only their boots, their small gloved human hands reaching out into the literal vastness of the entire freaking universe to try to catch 3000 pounds worth of metal foil and malfunctioning electronics.

01:13

Are you kidding me? This is real. This is real. And they got a small beam of light… Ha ha… True Weird Stuff. It's November 1997. Ally McBeal was the most popular show on television. Elton John's tribute to the recently deceased Princess Diana, Candle in the Wind 1997, that was the number one song in the country. More and more people were beginning to use email and websites, although dial-up connections were all most of us had to work with.

02:05

And there was no way yet to buy your tickets online to see America's number one movie, Mortal Kombat Annihilation. There was a whole bunch of talk and excitement around this new way of communicating. They called it text messaging. But in 1997, it only worked if both the sender and the receiver were on the same cellular network.

02:29

S-M-H-L-O-L, am I right? So that's just a quick review of what was happening down here on Earth in November 1997. But if you tipped your head back and looked up at the stars, you'd see that as a species, we were making some pretty breathtaking progress in space. And our story today begins in January 1972, when under President Richard Nixon, NASA announced the development of the space shuttle program.

02:57

Here's how this sexy government official made his case to the American people. There are perhaps four main reasons why the space shuttle is important. And is the right step in the manned space flight and the U.S. space program. First, the shuttle is the only meaningful new space, manned space program, which can be accomplished on a modest budget.

03:24

Second, the space shuttle is needed to make space operations less complex and less costly. Third, the space shuttle is needed to do many useful things. And fourth, the shuttle will encourage greater international cooperation in space flight. This guy, none of your lofty frontiers of knowledge, human ingenuity, exploring the unknown, blah, blah, blah here.

03:47

Nope. My man's all, look, it's not going to cost that much, OK? And we're going to do useful things, not just dick around in orbit. All right. So settle down and don't complain about the money. Jeez, people, damn. From there, things actually moved pretty fast, which is amazing when you consider the truly insane difficulties and brain crushing mathematics involved in pulling off manned space flight, not to mention the utter constipation of seemingly any government program.

04:15

You've got to hand it to NASA. Within four years of that announcement, they were testing the Enterprise Orbiter. Less than 10 years later, the space shuttle Columbia zoomed around the Earth 37 times before landing safely at Edwards Air Force Base. Man, the two crew members who took this wild ride were Robert L. Crippen and John W. Young.

04:39

I want to say their names because I think it's just kind of hilariously sad that we live in a world where everyone knows all the characters in Scooby Doo. But if our lives depended on it, could we name even 10 astronauts? Let's see. You have Neil Armstrong, John Glenn, Sally Ride, Gus Grissom, Captain Kirk. See what I mean?

05:03

By 1984, just 12 years later, Bruce McCandless II was casually doing himself a little untethered spacewalk from the comfort of the shuttle Challenger. And in a thrilling first, that crew even landed their shuttle mission in the very same place where it had taken off, which is something that not even Delta or American Airlines can always promise today.

05:27

I mean, the space shuttle program was straight up getting it done. In 1986, though, just 73 seconds into its 10th mission, the shuttle Challenger broke apart in flight. All seven crew members, including schoolteacher Kristen McAuliffe, were killed. It was a devastating tragedy that united the entire nation in grief. That night, President Ronald Reagan addressed the country.

06:01

The crew of the space shuttle Challenger honored us for the manner in which they lived their lives. We will never forget them, nor the last time we saw them this morning as they prepared for their journey and waved goodbye and slipped the surly bonds of Earth to touch the face of God. It was a terrible loss, the space shuttle Challenger.

06:26

And it didn't end the shuttle program, but it did end NASA's civilians in space initiative. That was over. In fact, that kind of civilian adventuring would have to wait another 35 years for billionaire Richard Branson to beat billionaire Jeff Bezos into space by just eight days. The press called it the billionaire space race because we're all basically living in a Gotham City packed with a bunch of Bruce Wayne types who have all of Batman's wealth, none of his altruistic desire to slip on a cape, get out there and battle some crime.

06:59

Anyhow, despite the Challenger tragedy, by 1997, the space shuttle program had racked up an impressive number of wins. In 1990, the crew of the shuttle Discovery successfully deployed the Hubble telescope into orbit, which I just made sound like no big deal. But holy space junk. Listen, you can't just open the bay doors and shove the Hubble out.

07:24

Not only did the thing cost more than a billion dollars to build and get into space, it was deployed at the highest orbital altitude ever attempted by the shuttle program. And then, of course, they got up there and they cut the Hubble loose and discovered that a mistake made during the manufacture of Hubble's primary mirror meant that, oops, things were just a little bit blurry.

07:49

And you could cry here or you could chuckle and shake your head at just how human, even the smartest human beings can be. But here's the thing. NASA had so much talent at every level of the shuttle program that just three years later, two teams of astronauts went up and performed a world record of five spacewalks to fix the Hubble's blurry eyesight.

08:15

Astounding. I mean, breathtaking. But by all means, let's do focus all of our attention on more important human achievements like Pete Davidson's inexplicable dating history. My God, humanity, seriously. So all of this eventually brings us to November 1997. NASA sent the shuttle Columbia on its 24th mission, a routine mission, as far as we know, because there were definitely top secret classified shuttle missions that we still know little to nothing about.

08:46

To this day, a whole bunch of them. I'm not saying it was the aliens, but I'm definitely saying it was the military and also probably the aliens, at least a little bit. And you can argue that, but since neither one of us knows anything for certain, it could be the aliens. Anyway, a routine mission, a routine mission that kicked off with a sassy little 180 degree roll of the shuttle Columbia as it raced toward orbit at 13 times the speed of sound.

09:15

Show off. NASA claimed the maneuver wasn't dangerous, but that it was necessary. And here's why. NASA's tracking station in Bermuda was about to be shut down to save a few bucks. The shuttle Columbia had to do that wild ass crazy 180 degree flip in order to be able to make radio contact with orbiting communication satellites or the crew of the Columbia would have been lost in space communications wise.

09:43

Oh, my God. There were no other places to scrimp and save. What is wrong with us? So a routine mission, but one that did fulfill one of the promises of the whole shuttle program made by that sparkling bureaucrat we heard from in the beginning of this episode. This program will be open to all the nations of the world. And it is his hope someday that foreign visitors from all over the world will be able to participate by moving to and from space in the space shuttle.

10:21

Check this out. Columbia's crew on this mission in November 1997 included astronauts from Japan, Ukraine and India. Actual foreign visitors participating in moving to and from space in the space shuttle, just like we were promised in 1972. And they say that government never keeps its promises. This routine mission was supposed to hurl into orbit and then retrieve a little satellite called Spartan.

10:49

The Spartan was meant to spend two days checking out the sun's outer atmosphere, clocking the solar winds and the charged particles, all the kinds of sun stuff that can wreak havoc with power grids and radio communication systems back here on Earth. And at the end of this 48 hour period, the astronauts on this mission would retrieve the satellite, tuck it safely away, practice a few spacewalks, do some top secret type stuff and have mysterious encounters with UFOs.

11:17

OK, well, I did make that last part up. But what happened instead was this extraordinary, I mean, mind bending feat of science, engineering and raw human courage. But those of us back on Earth were generally mostly oblivious to. And who can blame us? I mean, come on. We were all worked up about the movie Titanic, which was just about to be released to theaters.

11:42

And we were super busy cramming fistfuls of Nabisco snack wells into our pie holes because they told us we could eat all of them. We want it since they were fat free. And what a mother of high fructose corn syrup disaster that one turned out to be. I mean, come on. How are we supposed to do all of that? And pay attention to outer space, for God's sake.

12:02

Meanwhile, though, up on the Columbia, where they couldn't have snack wells unless they turned them into goo and squeezed them from a tube. Things were starting to go very wrong. Began with the satellite itself. Astronaut Kalpana Chawla released it, but the satellite did not perform what NASA adorably calls a pirouette.

12:25

This pirouette maneuver is supposed to demonstrate that all the systems on the little sun watcher satellite were working, but all of the systems were clearly not working. And you felt this kind of frustration yourself, trying to sync a soundbar to your TV or whatever. You're like, ah, now what? So astronaut Chawla tried the space equivalent of a reboot.

12:46

She attempted to gently and carefully grab the satellite back using the Columbia's 50 foot long shuttle arm. This was not successful, as anyone who's ever tried to snatch off a stuffed Pikachu from an arcade claw game can surely imagine. And making everything even worse, the failed attempt caused the satellite to begin slowly spinning, which made any further attempts to grab it with the shuttle arm borderline impossible.

13:15

So what do we do? Do we leave it there? Let its orbit decay till eventually it falls back to Earth, burning up in the atmosphere upon re-entry and hopefully not crashing into anybody's house? Nope. This little five foot square, three thousand pound satellite cost ten million dollars at a time when NASA apparently could not afford to maintain a tracking station and Bermuda for crying out loud.

13:42

A time when saving money was so critical that the top brass was like, OK, OK, hear me out. What if we just have the astronauts pull a little flipper move at like 13 times the speed of sound right after they launched? Can we maybe do that instead of maintaining that cash guzzling tracking station in Bermuda? People, let's all get on the same page with this.

14:02

And so now there's nothing left to do but suit up a couple of astronauts and send them out of the shuttle into the frigid negative 455 degrees Fahrenheit vastness of space to try to grab the damn thing with their hands while moving at about 17,500 miles an hour and gazing upon the actual planet Earth floating right there in front of them.

14:32

Talk about a complete, total, fully blown mind. I don't even know who developed the psychological screening system at NASA, but they are good. So now we have astronauts to cow, doy and Winston Scott standing on opposite ends of the shuttle's cargo bay for safety. They were attached to the surface of that platform by straps on their boots, which sounds like a terrifyingly low key restraint system.

15:04

I think you were probably more secure the last time you rode a roller coaster. And then they not only had to wait for Columbia to inch its way closer and closer and closer to the tumbling Spartan satellite. They also had to coordinate their movements down to the second. These two space cowboys would have just one chance, one chance to reach out and simultaneously grab the end of a telescope that was poking out from the side of the Spartan satellite.

15:34

They would both have to touch the telescope at the exact same moment. OK, and they're on a spaceship clamped down by their boots, staring at the planet Earth. And this operation took hours. Astronauts Doy and Scott clamped by their feet to an actual spaceship careening around the planet for hours, hours. Meanwhile, we're all down here on Earth like, oh, my God, have you seen that creepy dancing baby video that was on Ally McBeal?

16:05

You got to see this thing. It's wild. The crew of the shuttle Columbia could have said, oh, absolutely not mission control. Oh, hell no. Astronauts Doy and Scott could have at any time banged on the door and asked to come back inside the shuttle, especially after the first hour or so of standing there in the frigid void, contemplating the gazillion things that go really, really wrong, really, really fast.

16:30

They could have gotten tired and acted just a fraction of a second too soon or a fraction of a second too late, and the whole mission would have been a failure. But instead, they pulled off a near miraculous rescue. They literally snatched a dead satellite out of its doomed tumble and saved NASA $10 million. And not only that, they maintained their right stuff cool right up to the triumphant end.

17:02

I would like you to listen to these two astronauts casually asking if they could bring the rescued satellite back aboard. You guys, they were clamped by their feet to a spacecraft that was going 17,500 miles an hour for like over three hours swerving around the planet Earth. Did you hear how cool they just were? Have you not sounded more insane asking for someone to pass you the salt?

17:40

I myself am more jubilantly out of control every single time my dog remembers that he's supposed to poop outside the house. Can you even believe how cool these guys are? So maybe you're listening to this right now and you're thinking, wait a minute, the Space Shuttle Columbia. Didn't something terrible happen to the Space Shuttle Columbia?

18:03

Wasn't that all over the news? Well, you're right. Something terrible and heartbreaking did happen to the Columbia, but not on this particular mission. And this story of the Space Shuttle Columbia is not about tragedy. It's about wonder and about bravery and about science and math and how profoundly surreal and so weird it must be to be a very small human being orbiting the actual planet Earth for hours and hours, protected by nothing but your puffy suit and a helmet.

18:38

I mean, wow. Let's end this episode by hearing from that satellite fetching spacewalking hero of the stars, Columbia astronaut Winston Smith, who is trying to tell us as best he can what this kind of experience feels like. I can remember my very first spacewalk exiting the hatch and then floating up to the side of the walls in the payload bay.

19:11

I grabbed the handholds and I pulled myself up and I looked over and down at the Earth and I could see just how fast we were moving over the Earth and see how far below me the surface was. And I had the sensation I was falling. I was just going to tumble over and hit the ground. Well, of course, you are falling. That's how you stay in orbit.

19:32

You're literally falling around the Earth. But when you see it, you're outside and you see it with your own two eyes. It's just just an incredible experience that is difficult to express in words. We live in an age of wonders. It's just sometimes we need a little reminder to look up, to look up. Thanks for listening, Earthlings.

20:01

Next time on True Weird Stuff, who doesn't love a mother-daughter business, a little mommy and me fun? Except, you know, when they're stealing bodies and selling them for profit. Next time on True Weird Stuff. And we really appreciate it if you subscribe, rate and review True Weird Stuff. Hit our website, TrueWeirdStuff.com for show notes and photos and videos.

20:27

When we have it and bonus content. Everything True Weird is waiting for you at TrueWeirdStuff.com. And follow True Weird Stuff on Instagram and Twitter. True Weird Stuff is a Now! Media production. Our executive producer is Anthony Garcia. The show is written and hosted by me, Sheri Lynch, along with my deeply weird director, Max Sweeten.

20:49

Our equally odd producer is Kary Bowser. Additional production by the mysterious Stephen Call. Our digital witch and social media cult leader is Heather Furr. Original graphics by Kevin Nash. Original artworks by Olivia Axland. True Weird original music composed and performed by Jack Griffin and Zane Nash. Copyright 2023, Now! Media.

21:12

All rights reserved. All wrongs remembered.

One new weird tale a week.

The strangest true stories in history, in your inbox.

Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.